Skip to main content
scroll to top

NH Supreme Court Live Stream

 

2022 Supreme Court Oral Arguments
Date Argued Case Number Case     Video Link
09/20/22 2022-0154 Melissa Donovan
LML
(Sean R. List)
(15 min.)
v. Southern New Hampshire University
SPB&G
(Christopher N. Cole)
(15 min.)
View Video
09/20/22 2021-0394 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Elizabeth C. Woodcock)
(15 min.)
v. Caleb Douglas Marquis
Appellate Defender
(Stephanie C. Hausman)
(15 min.)
View Video
09/20/22 2021-0576 The Bibbo Poulin Revocable Trust
Bruce J. Marshall
(15 min.)
v. Nestle Waters North America, Inc.
KT
(James Michael Dunphy, Jr.)
(15 min.)
View Video
09/15/22 2021-0563 Petition of New Hampshire Division for Children, Youth and Families
Attorney General (Anthony J. Galdieri) (15 min.) for New Hampshire Division for Children, Youth and Families 
MM (Scott H. Harris) (15 min.) and T&T (Mary E. Tenn) for C.M., J.M., and M.M.
    View Video
09/15/22 2021-0570 Appeal of Town of Amherst
(New Hampshire Housing Appeals Board)
CB&Z (Christopher B. Drescher) (15 min.) for Town of Amherst
P&P (Gerald R. Prunier) (15 min.) for Migrela Realty Trust II and
GAM Realty Trust
    View Video
09/15/22 2021-0574 Estate of Bowen S. Downes & a.
PLC
(Gabriel Nizetic) 
(15 min.)
v. Dennis Greenwood
S-WS&S
(Brittney M. White)
(15 min.)
View Video
09/15/22 2021-0543 Christopher Andrews & a.
CB&Z 
(John G. Cronin)
(15 min.)
v. Kearsarge Lighting Precinct 
DW
(Demetrio F. Aspiras)
(15 min.) and
Hastings L/O
(Jason B. Dennis)
View Video
07/12/22 2021-0268 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Audriana Mekula-Hanson)
(15 min.)
v. Samuel Marino
Kirsten B. Wilson 
(15 min.) 
View Video
07/12/22 2021-0294 In the Matter of Gina DeSantis and Troy Cowell
Kelly E. Dowd (15 min.) for Gina DeSantis
Patrick J. Sheehan for Troy Cowell                     }
PPE&C (Doreen F. Connor) for the intervenors,   }  (15 min. total)
Albert Cowell and Virginia Cowell                       }
    View Video
06/23/22 2021-0361 Jeremy Fiske
Appellate Defender
(Thomas Barnard)
(15 min.) 
v. Warden, New Hampshire State Prison
Attorney General 
(Sam M. Gonyea)
(15 min.)
View Video
06/23/22 2021-0362 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General 
(Sam M. Gonyea)
(15 min.) 
v. Tony Hebert
Appellate Defender
(Thomas Barnard)
(15 min.) 
View Video
06/23/22 2021-0161 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General 
(Zachary L. Higham) 
(15 min.)
v. Jesse Warren
Appellate Defender
(Thomas A. Barnard)
(15 min.)
View Video
06/23/22 2021-0322 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Elizabeth C. Woodcock)
(15 min.)
v. Andrew M. Fletcher
Appellate Defender 
(Christopher M. Johnson) 
(15 min.)
View Video
06/21/22 2021-0473 Appeal of Town of Windham
(New Hampshire Housing Appeals Board)
B&C (Bernard H. Campbell) (15 min.) for Town of Windham
CB&Z (John G. Cronin) (15 min.) for Ten Harris Road, LLC
    View Video
06/21/22 2021-0476 Appeal of Chichester Commons, LLC
(New Hampshire Housing Appeals Board)
O&R (John L. Arnold) (15 min.) for Chichester Commons, LLC
U&H (Nathan C. Midolo) (15 min.) for Town of Chichester
    View Video
06/21/22 2021-0448 Christine Christian
William Aivalikles
(15 min.) 
v. Suzan A. Messina
MM
(Linda M. Smith) 
(15 min.)
View Video
06/14/22 2021-0376 CC 145 Main, LLC
SL&V
(Henry B. Stebbins)
(15 min.)
v. Union Mutual Fire Insurance Company
PPE&C
(Gary M. Burt) 
(15 min.)
View Video
06/14/22 2021-0338 Jerry Gaucher
Seufert L/O
(Christopher C. Snook)
(15 min.)
v. Gary E. Waterhouse, Trustee & a.
Steven G. Shadallah for 
Gary E. Waterhouse, Trustee, and Waterhouse Country Store, Inc.
(15 min.) 
View Video
05/31/22 2022-0184 Theresa Norelli & a.
PC
(John Devaney, pro hac 
vice) and
MM
(Steven J. Dutton)
Amici: ACLU-NH
(Henry R. Klementowicz) 
for American Civil 
Liberties Union of New 
Hampshire
S&G
(James J. Armillay, Jr.)
for New Hampshire 
House of 
Representatives 
Minority Leader and 
New Hampshire Senate 
Minority Leader
(15 min. total)
v. Secretary of State & a.
Attorney General
(Myles B. Matteson) for Secretary of State
Attorney General
(Samuel R.V. Garland) for State of New 
Hampshire
LML
(Sean R. List) for Speaker of New 
Hampshire House of Representatives
LML
(Richard J. Lehmann) for President of
New Hampshire Senate
(15 min. total)
View Video
05/19/22 2022-0184 Theresa Norelli & a.
PC
(John Devaney, pro hac vice)
(20 min.)
v. Secretary of State & a.
Attorney General
(Myles B. Matteson) for Secretary of State
(Sean R. List) for Speaker of New Hampshire House of Representatives
LML
(Richard J. Lehmann) for President of New Hampshire Senate
(20 min. total)
View Video
05/10/22 2021-0087 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Elizabeth C. Woodcock)
(15 min.)
v. Kevin Butler
CL
(Jared J. Bedrick) 
(15 min.)
View Video
05/04/22 2021-0478 Cassandra Caron & a.
PL
(Michael Perez)
(15 min.) 
v. New Hampshire Department of Employment Security & a.
Attorney General 
(Nathan W. Kenison-Marvin)
(15 min.)
View Video
05/04/22 2021-0243 Appeal of The Lawson Group & a. 
(Compensation Appeals Board)
B&M (Gary S. Harding) (15 min.) for The Lawson Group
Attorney General (John F. Brown) (15 min.) for Special Fund for Second Injuries 
    View Video
05/04/22 2022-0184 Theresa Norelli & a.
PC
(John Devaney, pro hac vice)
Amicus: ACLU-NH
(Henry R. Klementowicz) for American Civil Liberties Union of New Hampshire
(30 min. total)
v. Secretary of State & a.
Attorney General
(Myles B. Matteson) for Secretary of State
Attorney General
(Samuel R.V. Garland) for State of New Hampshire
LML
(Sean R. List) for Speaker of New Hampshire House of Representatives
LML
(Richard J. Lehmann) for President of New Hampshire Senate
(30 min. total)
View Video
04/21/22 2021-0357 Marc Mallard
WS&P
(Michael G. Eaton)
(15 min.) 
v. Warden, New Hampshire State Prison
Attorney General 
(Zachary L. Higham) 
(15 min.) 
View Video
04/21/22 2021-0093 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General 
(Peter Hinckley)
(15 min.) 
v. Timothy R. Verrill
Appellate Defender 
(David M. Rothstein)
(15 min.) 
View Video
04/21/22 2021-0325 Daniel Richard
for himself 
(15 min.)
v. Speaker of the House of Representatives & a. 
James S. Cianci for Speaker of the House of Representatives
LML (Richard J. Lehman) for 
New Hampshire Senate President
(15 min. total) 
View Video
04/14/22 2016-0006 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Elizabeth C. Woodcock)
(15 min.) 
v. Ernesto Rivera
Appellate Defender 
(Christopher M. Johnson) 
(15 min.)
View Video
04/14/22 2021-0009 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General 
(Elizabeth C. Woodcock)
(15 min.) 
v. Ernesto Rivera
Appellate Defender 
(Christopher M. Johnson) 
(15 min.)
View Video
04/14/22 2021-0267 Appeal of New Hampshire Division of State Police
(Personnel Appeals Board)
Attorney General (Jessica A. King) (15 min.) for 
New Hampshire Division of State Police
M&K (Marc G. Beaudoin) (15 min.) for Eric Call
    View Video
04/14/22 2020-0404 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Zachary L. Higham) 
(15 min.) 
v. Corey V. Donovan
Appellate Defender
(Thomas A. Barnard) 
(15 min.)
View Video
04/14/22 2021-0369 Appeal of Caitlyn Wittenauer
(Compensation Appeals Board) 
NC&O (James F. Lafrance) (15 min.) for Caitlyn Wittenauer
M&M (Matthew J. Solomon) (15 min.) for Nike, Inc. 
    View Video
03/29/22 2021-0356 Jeff Acker & a.
SF&B
(Nathan H. Stearns)
(15 min.) 
v. Town of Hanover 
MMG
(Laura Spector-Morgan) for 
Town of Hanover
WS&P
(Michael J. Tierney) for 
Christ Redeemer Church
(15 min. total)
View Video
03/29/22 2021-0349 Christ Redeemer Church
WS&P
(Michael J. Tierney)
(15 min.)
v. Town of Hanover
GC&G
(Robert J. Dietel) and 
MMG 
(Laura Spector-Morgan) for 
Town of Hanover
SF&B
(Nathan H. Stearns) for 
Jeff Acker and Lara Acker
(15 min. total)
View Video
03/29/22 2021-0147 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General 
(Zachary L. Higham)
(15 min.)
v. Robert Leroux
Appellate Defender
(Christopher M. Johnson) 
(15 min.) 
View Video
03/29/22 2021-0148 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General 
(Zachary L. Higham)
(15 min.)
v. Robert Leroux
Appellate Defender
(Christopher M. Johnson)
(15 min.)
View Video
03/17/22 2021-0423 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Elizabeth C. Woodcock)
(15 min.)
v. Ernest Justin Blanchette
DH 
(Brad C. Davis) 
(15 min.)
View Video
03/17/22 2021-0280 Cincinnati Specialty Underwriters Insurance Company
GSS&P
(Christopher J. Poulin) 
(15 min.)
v. Best Way Homes, Inc. & a.
VDCR&R
(Cristina Rousseau) for Russell Blodgett
(15 min.) 
View Video
03/15/22 2021-0213 Tycollo Graham
Nicholson L/F
(Keith F. Diaz) 
(15 min.)
v. Eurosim Construction & a.
S&H
(Trevor J. Brown) (15 min.) for
Eurosim Construction
O&A (Peter J. Hamilton) for
ProCon, Inc.
View Video
03/15/22 2021-0248 Appeal of State of New Hampshire
(Public Employee Labor Relations Board)
Attorney General (Laura E. B. Lombardi) for the State 
(15 min.)
SEA (Gary J. Snyder) for State Employees’ Association of New 
Hampshire, SEIU Local 1984
NP (Peter J. Perroni) for New England Police Benevolent 
Association, Locals 40 and 45
(15 min. total)
    View Video
03/15/22 2021-0214 TransFarmations, Inc. 
DT&C 
(Brendan A. O’Donnell)
(15 min.)
v. Town of Amherst
CB&Z 
(Christopher B. Drescher)
(15 min.)
View Video
03/15/22 2021-0166 Marc Chartier & a.
AB&D
(Jared R. Green)
(15 min.)
v. Apple Therapy of Londonderry, 
LLC & a.
WS&P
(Todd Hathaway)
(15 min.) for Apple Therapy of 
Londonderry, LLC
MM (Tory Weigand, pro hac vice, 
and Justin R. Veiga) for Four 
Seasons Orthopaedic Center, 
PLLC and Heather C. Killie, M.D.
View Video
02/23/22 2021-0151 Nikolas Gascard & a.
Nikolas Gascard, nonlawyer, for Lorettann Gascard
(15 min.)
v. Andrew J. Hall & a.
Desmarais L/G (Debra L. Mayotte) for Andrew J. Hall
O&R (William L. Chapman)
for Newspapers of New Hampshire, Inc. d/b/a Concord Monitor
(15 min. total)
View Video
02/23/22 2021-0392 Appeal of City of Rochester
(Board of Tax and Land Appeals) 
City Attorney (Terence M. O’Rourke) (15 min.) for City of Rochester
Marcia A. Brown (15 min.) for Rochester Agricultural & Mechanical Association 
    View Video
02/23/22 2021-0197 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Zachary L. Higham) 
(15 min.)
v. Juan Alberto Monegro-Diaz
Dixon L/O
(Simon Dixon)
Amicus:  Matthew McNicoll for New Hampshire Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
(15 min. total)
View Video
02/23/22 2021-0358 State of New Hampshire & a.
KD&W (David Zalman, pro hac vice) (15 min.) and 
Attorney General (Christopher G. Aslin) for State of New Hampshire
v. 3M Company & a.
BB (Katherine L.I. Hacker, pro hac vice) (15 min.) and 
U&H (Brooke Lovett Shilo) for Corteva, Inc. and DuPont de Nemours, Inc.
View Video
02/17/22 2021-0053 Appeal of Tradz, LLC
(Department of Safety, Bureau of Hearings)
WS&P (Stephen Zaharias) (15 min.) for Tradz, LLC
Attorney General (Christina Wilson) (15 min.) for 
New Hampshire Division of Motor Vehicles
    View Video
02/17/22 2019-0047 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Elizabeth C. Woodcock)
(15 min.)
v. Brim Bell
Appellate Defender
(Thomas A. Barnard)
(15 min.)
View Video
02/17/22 2021-0222 Appeal of Robert Newcomb & a.
(Wetlands Council)
CB&Z (John G. Cronin) (15 min.) for Robert Newcomb and Carolyn Newcomb
Attorney General (Joshua C. Harrison) (15 min.) for New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services
    View Video
02/17/22 2021-0286 Petition of Cellco Partnership d/b/a Verizon Wireless
(Department of Natural and Cultural Resources)
MM (Michael A. Delaney) (15 min.) for Cellco Partnership
Attorney General (Michael R. Haley) (15 min.) for Commissioner, New Hampshire Department of Natural and Cultural Resources
    View Video
02/17/22 2021-0418 K.T.
Russman L/O
(Sheliah M. Kaufold)
(15 min.)
v. M.K.
BSS&N
(Roy W. Tilsley, Jr.)
(15 min.)
View Video
02/15/22 LD-2021-0012 In the Matter of Robert M. Fojo, Esquire
Attorney Discipline Office 
(Mark P. Cornell and Elizabeth M. Murphy) (15 min.)
PFB&P (William C. Saturley) for Robert M. Fojo, Esquire 
(15 min.)
    View Video
02/10/22 2021-0194 S.C.
Sven D. Wiberg
(15 min.)
v. G.C.
H&Z
(Mark D. Hanlon)
(15 min.)
View Video
02/10/22 2021-0187 Appeal of Elba Hawes
(Compensation Appeals Board)
DL&G (Benjamin T. King) (15 min.) for Elba Hawes
M&M (Craig A. Russo) (15 min.) for Asplundh Tree Expert, LLC
    View Video
02/10/22 2020-0364 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Zachary L. Higham)
(15 min.)
v. Richard Racette
Appellate Defender
(Christopher M. Johnson)
(15 min.)
View Video
02/10/22 2021-0071
2021-0072

Appeal of Javier Vasquez
Appeal of Matosantos International Corporation
(Compensation Appeals Board)

S&G (Jared P. O’Connor) for Javier Vasquez 
RY&P (Michael K. O’Neil) for Matosantos International Corporation
(15 min. total)

GSS&P (Tracy L. McGraw) for The Hartford Insurance Company
Attorney General (Stacie M. Moeser) for New Hampshire Department of Labor
(15 min. total)

    View Video
02/10/22 2020-0570 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Anthony J. Galdieri)
(15 min.)
v. Justin Parr
LML
(Sean R. List)
(15 min.)
View Video
02/10/22 2021-0211 In the Matter of Rehabilitation of The Home Insurance Company
MM (Mark C. Rouvalis) and F&P (Peter B. Steffen, pro hac vice) 
(15 min.) for Zurich Insurance PLC, German Branch
VD (J. David Leslie) (15 min.) for the Insurance Commissioner, as Liquidator of The Home Insurance Company
WS&P (Michael J. Tierney) and KMCL (Paul K. Stockman, pro hac vice) for certain policyholder appellees
    View Video
01/27/22 2021-0114 Ajit Kumar
S-WS&S
(Tanya L. Spony) 
(15 min.)
v. SNHS Management Corporation
G&H
(Paul M. DeCarolis) 
(15 min.)
View Video
01/27/22 2020-0148 State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Zachary L. Higham)
(15 min.) 
v. Javon Brown
Appellate Defender
(Thomas A. Barnard)
(15 min.)
View Video
01/27/22 2021-0253 Laura Colquhoun
LML
(Richard J. Lehmann)
(15 min.)
v. City of Nashua
Office of Corporation Counsel
(Nicole M. Clay)
(15 min.)
View Video
01/27/22 2021-0274 Andrea Amodeo-Vickery
BA-V&B
(Christopher A. Bandazian)
(15 min.)
v. Town of Salem
U&H
(Russell F. Hilliard)
(15 min.)
View Video
01/27/22 2021-0142 Thomas S. Wood & a.
Sharon J. Rondeau
(15 min.)
v. Town of Raymond
DW&M 
(Keriann Roman) 
(15 min.)
View Video
01/27/22 2019-0130
2020-0331
State of New Hampshire
State of New Hampshire
Attorney General
(Elizabeth C. Woodcock) 
(15 min.)
v.
v.
Pamela Mansulla
Pamela Mansulla
Appellate Defender
(Stephanie C. Hausman)
(15 min.)
View Video
01/13/22 2021-0085 Appeal of Suzanne Fournier & a.
(Department of Environmental Services Water Council)
RY&P (Craig T. McMahon) (15 min.) for the petitioners
Attorney General (Christopher G. Aslin) for New Hampshire 
Department of Environmental Services (15 min.)
R&S (Biron L. Bedard) for the intervenor
    View Video
01/13/22 2021-0139 George Stergiou & a.
Scott E. Hogan, for the plaintiffs, no brief filed
DT&C
(William K. Warren)
(15 min.) for the
intervenors
v. City of Dover
City Attorney
(Joshua M. Wyatt) 
(15 min.)
View Video
01/13/22 2021-0075 In the Matter of Matthew Kostiew and Alejandra Flores
U&H (Michael S. McGrath) (15 min.) for Matthew Kostiew
Christine G. DeBernardis (15 min.) for Alejandra Flores
    View Video
01/11/22 2021-0244 Daniel J. Barufaldi
DL&G
(Benjamin T. King)
(15 min.)
v. City of Dover
City Attorney
(Joshua M. Wyatt)
(15 min.)
View Video